I saw two crime related movies recently. ”The Town” and “Gomorrah”. The first movie is the second directorial effort from Ben Affleck. He wrote and stars in the movie also. I don’t know how much of the movie he actually directed, because many of the action scenes are quiet involved and speak either to a an encyclopedic memory of action films or an uncanny ability to get the right action at the right time. The action scenes are quite good. This movie is about a section of Boston that has raised up a lot of bank robbers. Doug MacRay (Affleck) leads a robbery crew where his opposite is James Coughlin (Jeremy Renner). They work for Fergie Colm (Pete Postelwaite). The crew is pursued by FBI agent Adam Frawley (Jon Hamm). Krista Coughlin (Blake Lively), James sister and Doug’s lover, vies with Claire Keesey (Rebecca Hall) for Doug’s affections. How did he meet Claire? By sticking up the bank at which she is the assistant manager. James takes her hostage and Doug stalks her to make see if she knows anything. It turns out she does, but it doesn’t matter in the grand scheme of things.
The story is as old as time, and parallels the story of Jonathan Wild, except that Fergie isn’t a Thief Taker. There were very few beats to this story that I didn’t see coming. There is an air of realism to it that has a cinematic quality, which means that it isn’t really realistic, it only appears so for the purposes of cinema. There were times when the movie could have been speeded up with no real loss of story, and Affleck love of the two shot close up pulled me out of the movie and left me wondering about how else it could have been staged.
The story doesn’t lend itself to nuanced story telling. This is a movie where the only color of character is in the primary range. Bold is the starting point and over-the-top is about medium. The women are the only characters who show any vulnerability. Claire had fewer opportunites, but Blake Lively as Krista has more and delivers when she can.
Jeremy Renner got good reviews, but his is pretty much a one note character, and Renner plays it like it is a gong. Some people like that sort of character in a movie. There were a few changes I would have made to the story to provide it with a bit more moral grounding. Doug has an existentialist journey, but that isn’t made clear. Claire has a decision that will illuminate her sense of morality, but we don’t really see it. Agent Frawley is not really explored to provide a clear moral picture of who he is and why he does what he does. Many of these quibbles could have been covered easily, but the movie doesn’t do it.
It was an enjoyable action picture and speaks to Ben Affleck’s organizational skills. Running a movie shoot requires a tremendous amount of attention to detail before one even tries to deliver on the art that one is attempting. Affleck has that skill.
“Gommorah” is a movie based on the book of the same name by Roberto Saviano. That book is about the crime families of Naples called the Cammora. Saviano has had to leave Italy because of death threats on his life by members of the Cammora.
The movie uses interconnected stories and a large cast to tell several stories about the Cammora. This movie has a more realistic feel than “The Town”. It has a gritty look of deep focus and what we can see in the deep focus isn’t pretty. Aging apartment buildings, abandoned buildings, rust everywhere.
The movie has no heroes. But maybe that is the way things are for people engaged in criminal activity in Naples. I have seen a viral video (available on Youtube) of a man being shot in Naples. It is the surveillance footage from a corner shop. The gunman nonchalantly walks up in back of the victim, shoots him in the head, and nonchalantly walks away. Many people saw the killer’s face, but no one was willing to speak.
Italy has a plunging birth rate. Society can become unstable with an aging population and an influx of immigrants who don’t speak the language and don’t know the customs. The government is the problem in that government corruption hinders efforts to establish and enforce the rule of law.
The movie is interesting, if only for a voyeuristic view of rampant pathology.