Posted on Saturday 12 February 2011
I picked up a book called “Lead Us Not Into Temptation” about 10 years ago. It was about sex abuse within the United States Catholic church and the response of the church to claims of sex abuse. It was pretty gut wrenching to read. In this article about sex abuse Catholic churches in Ireland, there were some unsettling facts.
In Ireland the stakes for the Vatican are tangible. The abuse reports have led to popular demands that the state disentangle the Catholic Church from the country’s infrastructure. More than 90 percent of primary schools are under church patronage — even though they are state-financed — so that parents generally have no choice but to place their children in a school with what is called a Catholic ethos. Most public hospitals are also controlled by the church, which means that certain procedures that would be commonplace elsewhere have been problematic in Ireland. These include not just abortions — which in December the European Court of Human Rights decreed that Ireland must permit in cases where a woman’s life is at risk — but also vasectomies, among others.
What the hell? Ireland is functioning as a theocracy.
There were those — like the playwrightGeorge Bernard Shaw and the poet William Butler Yeats — who thought that the potential break with England constituted an occasion for Ireland to cut the strings to the Catholic Church and to embrace a progressive, international sensibility. Others wrapped Irish patriotism together with Catholicism, agrarian traditions and the Gaelic language, and they won the day. Eamon De Valera, the political leader, drafted a constitution side by side with the all-powerful archbishop of Dublin, John Charles McQuaid, which gave the Catholic Church a special role in state affairs and which to this day begins with the words, “In the name of the most holy trinity.”
It is time for at least the Reformation to come to Ireland.

